'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (2024)

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (1)Jacob Smith |

May 21, 2024

  • Share on Gab
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Flipboard
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share on News Break
  • Share via Email

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (2)

I have to be straightforward with you. I’m probably the lowest end of the totem pole when it comes to being the target demographic for Back to Black, the biopic about the life and death of Amy Winehouse.

Even in the mid-2000s, when Amy Winehouse began her rise to worldwide popularity, I never understood her appeal.

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (3)

A woman who at her peak looked like she was on the verge of death became a worldwide sensation singing about her refusal to go to rehab; only to die from alcohol poisoning just a few short years later. When Amy Winehouse passed away, many believed the singer was one of the best voices of our generation.

Maybe that’s true for some of you guys living in the UK, but I saw something completely different being born and raised in the United States. Despite my personal opinions about the singer, it certainly wasn’t going to stop Studio Canal and Focus Features in moving forward on the latest musical biopic Back to Black.

When it comes to the Amy Winehouse story, this is a film that Hollywood has tried to create ever since she died in 2011. But one project after another had fallen through the cracks until they were finally able to put wheels in motion of this story.

Back to Black tells the story of Amy Winehouse, played by Marisa Abela, as she is introduced to audiences as a young Jewish woman growing up in the streets of the Greater London areas — where she found herself in trouble more often than not.

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (4)

One day, Amy is discovered by an executive at Island Records, who offers to sign her to a deal to showcase her voice and her image to a much larger audience. After maintaining some early success, the record label decides to step in and make some changes to Amy’s presentation in hopes of gaining even a bigger following overseas.

This was the first of many bad decisions that led to the emotional downfall of the singer. Over the next few years, Amy’s life revolves around bad relationships, drug problems, alcohol abuse, and the consequences of dealing with the fame monster that she is not mentally or physically prepared to accept.

The screenwriter for this project is Matt Greenhalgh, a British writer who got critical acclaim for his biopic of Ian Curtis, lead singer of the late ’70s band Joy Division. The studio figured that if Greenhalgh was successful at one musical biopic with a big name British artist, he could certainly regain that success with the story of Amy Winehouse.

The director of this film is Sam Taylor-Johnson — the woman who is famously known for her relationship with Aaron Taylor-Johnson, which started when she was 42 when he was 18. Take away the films that she directed with her husband, and the only film on her resume is Fifty Shades of Grey.

That alone should tell you that we’re off to a terrible start with this project.

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (6)

It’s hard to watch this film and not think to that lead star Marisa Abela was set up to fail. The actress comes off as a cosplay version of Amy Winehouse, especially when she tried to lip sync over the vocals from Amy’s tracks. Because the film did not hire someone with an actual singing background, Back to Black, has to create a lot of movie magic in order to make the film somewhat presentable.

The fact that they have to dance around so many flaws in the film’s hiring choice is one thing. Another major flaw is Back to Black was trying to tell about the lowest points in the life of Amy Winehouse without having the film go to a complete drag, which means that the film admittedly omits more than one disturbing detail about her life.

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (7)

The storytelling of this movie is very vanilla. If you have no recollection about who Amy Winehouse was, outside of her hit song ‘Rehab,’ you’re not going to find out any new information watching this movie. If you’re a fan of Amy Winehouse, you’re going to find yourself struggling between the fact that this movie managed to fall short of the story of her life as well as the story behind her music as well.

Leaving you with a film that is likely going to shatter your doe-eyed remembrance of a once-famous singer and a story that’s arguably about 10 years too late, Back to Black is a film that’s about as dreadful as the final years of Amy Winehouse’s life.

NEXT: ‘Mars Express’ Review – France’s Anime Film Is A Cyberpunk Standout

Back to Black (2024), Studio Canal

1

OVERALL SCORE

PROS

  • Authentic UK story.

CONS

  • Miscast lead.
  • Soft story.
  • No focus.

Share:

  • Share on Gab
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Flipboard
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share on News Break
  • Share via Email
Mentioned This Article:Amy Winehouse Back to Black Island Records Marisa Abela Matt Greenhalgh Sam Taylor-Johnson

More About:Movie Reviews Movies Reviews

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals (2024)

FAQs

'Back To Black' Review - A Biopic That Misses The Mark With Fans And Casuals? ›

Another major flaw is Back to Black was trying to tell about the lowest points in the life of Amy Winehouse without having the film go to a complete drag, which means that the film admittedly omits more than one disturbing detail about her life. The storytelling of this movie is very vanilla.

Why is Back to Black getting bad reviews? ›

In the case of Back to Black, though, the depiction of Winehouse rings both false and strikingly convenient for the people who were involved in her life. As Jason P. Frank and Rebecca Alter write in Vulture, the film spends too much time “trying to reclaim her as wholesome,” against the tabloids' vilifying coverage.

Is the movie Back to Black a good movie? ›

Critics Reviews

This papering over of Winehouse and her story isn't just bland and boring — it's offensive. Content collapsed. Much like the rabid tabloid coverage Winehouse faced, Back to Black is a lazy attempt to capitalize on both the success and struggles of a great artist.

How accurate was Back to Black? ›

That said, most of the major events depicted in the film are true, and indeed several of Winehouse's most iconic live performances – and a famous early interview with Jonathan Ross – are recreated faithfully.

What is the Back to Black movie about? ›

What is the controversy with the movie Back to Black? ›

Early comments criticized Abela's appearance while wearing Winehouse's signature beehive and heavy eye makeup, both of which are messy during a scene on the street. Fans called it "revolting" and claimed the movie was exploiting and sensationalizing her story, per the BBC.

What Back to Black got wrong? ›

The exploitatively inaccurate conclusion of Back to Black gets several facts wrong. In reality, Amy had been dating a man named Reg Traviss for one year by the time she was sober in her new Camden home. Furthermore, Blake's baby was not born until May 2011, two months before Amy died of alcohol poisoning in July 2011.

What does Blake think of back to black? ›

Blake has seen the film and loves it. He said some really very moving words and his feedback has been beyond my expectation,” O'Connell shares. “I won't delve too much into our private conversation, as I don't want to speak out of turn, but his review was massively important. “

How truthful is Back to Black? ›

Back to Black depicts Winehouse and Fielder-Civil's first meeting almost exactly as it happened. According to an interview with the Daily Mail, Fielder-Civil arrived at the Good Mixer, a pub in London's Camden neighborhood after a big gambling win and Winehouse was the first person he saw there.

Why isn't Mark Ronson in Back to Black? ›

The Mail quotes the biopic's producers who explained: “The character of Mark Ronson has never appeared on screen in the film, so it would not have been possible to 'cut all the scenes' involving Mark Ronson as they do not exist.”

Is Back to Black worth watching? ›

Back to Black is a fitfully enjoyable little package that will do wonders for the careers of Abela and O'Connell. But unlike Winehouse's oeuvre, it's not worth taking seriously. It's just too afraid of the dark. Dir: Sam Taylor-Johnson.

What happened to Amy Winehouse's husband? ›

Since her death

Though Fielder-Civil continued to struggle with his own drug addiction following Winehouse's death, he revealed in April on “Good Morning Britain” that he's been “clean for years.”

How did Amy Winehouse lose her teeth? ›

Indeed, in an interview with MTV, Winehouse admitted that “My tooth got knocked out, that's true,” adding, “I bit down on an ice cube and felt it come loose. I was sitting with my boyfriend and told him he had to pull it out because it was going to come out at some point and would be horrible and bloody.

Is Back to Black a flop? ›

Box office. As of 17 July 2024, Back to Black has grossed $6.2 million in the United States and Canada and $44.9 million in other territories, for a worldwide total of $51.1 million. Back to Black debuted at number one in the UK and Ireland with £2.77 million ($3.4 million), ahead of Civil War.

Is Back to Black a good product? ›

Works great! I used this to re-dye my black jeans. The product was phenomenal, my jeans look like new!

Is Back to Black a failed biopic of Amy Winehouse? ›

The new "Back to Black" film, which walks the line between a biopic and a dramatic retelling of Winehouse's relationship with ex-husband Blake Fielder-Civil, failed to capture the same Amy the world has missed since her death, due to accidental alcohol poisoning, in 2011 at 27 years old.

What does Blake think of Back to Black? ›

Blake has seen the film and loves it. He said some really very moving words and his feedback has been beyond my expectation,” O'Connell shares. “I won't delve too much into our private conversation, as I don't want to speak out of turn, but his review was massively important. “

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Last Updated:

Views: 5914

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (46 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Birthday: 2001-01-17

Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

Phone: +813077629322

Job: Real-Estate Executive

Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.